I mean by pollution, you have 19 years old kids in the twenties category, there’s no clear policy how to handle 19 and under, that category is polluted with 19 year olds - those who might or might not have the permission from their parents, which is not clear how to handle it on Common Voice.
Congratulations this is called data managment or data adjustment.
If a court/person gets the impression: underage and biometric voice recordings and saving/releasing/processing this without proof of doing so…oh my good night.
In the worst case (without proof of permission) this would mean a full wipe of those underage clips (and not moving the clips to graveyard!)
No offense,no harm, just my concerns!
-A solution could be: CV legal terms based on the country from which you are contributing (and for what language) It is exactly stated what age is required (in that country) for contributing without permission as adult. Cv has no interest in underage clips.
[But how to deal with vpn/tor/anonymous contributers???]
- Building up CV servers for every continent/country, collecting the data under the legal terms of this continent/country and relasing that language from there to the public. (much more expensive)
The language community (for this country) decides if underage clips are collected and how to deal with permissions.
For contributing as underage : 2 permissions from different emails for the underage account??? - if cv is interested in underage clips.
Also, i guess a common (actual) practice is: using the account of the adult to record also the child.
So much for the “pollution” - misleading labelling of voice clips included.
I also doubt that a fully grown up/adult 16 year old united kingdom contributer is asking his parents for permission to contribute to CV and they supervise them, because CV is stating over 19 in their terms. And here comes the best part:
They do not have to do so in the uk (uk law)!
CV must find a way to value diverse laws for different countries/continents, especially on a project with this big scale. The declared age by CV is not valid for the rest of the world.
What are the future plans of CV/Mozilla dealing with this “situation” ? Talk to us!