Can FF's superb Reopen Tab / Reopen Closed Window logic be restored, please?

Dear Mozilla Firefox Team,

In FF v116.0 the behavior of the “Undo Close Tab” Keyboard shortcut changed.

Previously, one could reopen closed tabs or windows independently using their own respective keyboard shortcuts.
Since v116.0 the keyboard shortcuts to reopen tabs acts as a global “undo” across all windows (even closed windows).

This makes the feature’s functionality so much worse in my opinion, that I at first filed a bug report for it:

Through this I identified that the change was made intentionally, as can be read here:

I am personally extremely passionate about this feature and would like to plead the case for the original functionality to be either restored or brought back as a user setting.

I love Firefox. Firefox is a true workhorse for browsing, contributing to the web as well as research. The previous functionality of this feature allowed me to use Firefox (over all other browsers out there) for my daily tasks comprising extended research efforts, as every window kept it’s own history of recently closed tabs and restoring each worked independently of each other.

I use FF windows to group thematically related tabs in one window. I have at least 2-3 windows open and am switching between them at all times.
I sometimes have tens of windows open in parallel, often for months, many of them minimized (I work on Mac) and waiting for their time to come.
Individual windows may represent different parallel research sessions, kept available and quickly accessible / ready for me to jump back into the individual session and continue where I left off.

With the old functionality I could pull up a window from 4 months ago, remember that during that research session I had recently closed a tab which had the subject matter info I need, restore a couple tabs via keyboard and voilà.

Even for just daily work, I’ll be in a workflow, open a separate “Ad-hoc” window to look up 2-3 things, close that “Ad-hoc” window and wish to proceed with my work. Often I wish to reopen a closed tab of my actual work window because of what I just found out in my “Ad-hoc” window. This workflow is now completely broken.

I could provide more affected patterns.

The feature change “dumbs down” the functionality, which I understand may be the intention and with 10 years UX & product experience myself I understand my ways of working may not match those of the average FF user or intended user behavior.

I personally dislike the change as the feature really differentiated FF as a pro tool for my web browsing needs.
I am seriously frightened this functionality may not come back and I will lose access to the feature which has been my main reason for choosing and never switching away from FF.
This has been at the core of my daily workflow for almost 2 decades now.

I implore you guys and gals to consider this feedback and reintroduce the reason I preferred FF over all the other browsers for all these years, at least as a user or configuration preference.

Thank you for your consideration.
A Firefox Fan

1 Like

This hasn’t had much traction, but I feel I agree.

Ctrl+Shift+T => Reopen Tab in Window
Ctrl+Shift+N => Reopen Window

I’m not sure for certain, but I feel the new change may have reduced the number of stored tabs. If everything is in the same list then there’s going to be a global cap vs a per-window cap, right?

1 Like

Seems like this is part of a bigger change on how “reopen tabs” behaves. A change that I am /definitely/ not a fan of. Tabs should be localized to windows. It makes the most sense. And, according to the bugzilla, they’re going to be localized to private windows. So it sounds like they’ll need to maintain TWO codepaths now. 1. Localized to windows. 2. Global tab list. That seems super silly.

1 Like

Yeah @Sxderp it feels like this change is not thought all the way through.
There is also some more reding here:

It is seriously messing with the ability to reopen tabs and definitely the cmd+t keyboard shortcut is now broken, as in it will restore the (global) previous tab or window, and with the next press break that pattern and keep restoring tabs in that same window only.

I’m unsure what to do about it, but it’s frustrating this seems to be going almost unnoticed.

I hate this new logic so much. I genuinely thought it was a bug, that would be fixed soon enough. Eventually got so sick of it and went to make a bug report, and found this. :frowning:

Does anybody know if there’s an extension to restore the old behavior?

I also feel like this new “design” must be bugged in some way, because often I close a window, try to bring it back, and I get back an older window that I closed earlier instead of the one I closed moments ago. I continue trying to restore closed tabs/windows and just get ones from further and further back into the past, instead of the one I just closed. I can’t figure out a way to bring back the one I just closed, give up, and navigate back to it manually.

1 Like